TOPIC:

Picture courtesy of DNW

MBE (Military), hallmarks for London 1918;
Sudan (2489. O:R: Sgt. R. Williams. 1/Cam: Hrs.);
QSA (4) Cape Colony, Johannesburg, Diamond Hill, Wittebergen (2489 O-R: Sejt. R. Williams, 1: Cam’n: H’Drs:);
KSA (2) South Africa 1901, South Africa 1902 (2489 Clr:-Serjt: R. Williams. Cameron Highrs:);
1914-15 Star, unnamed;
BWM and VM with MID oak leaves (3-6204 T.W.O.Cl.1. R. C. Williams. Cam’n Highrs.);
Army LS&GC EdVII (2489 Q.M. Sjt: R. Williams. Cameron Hdrs.);
MSM GV 1st issue (3-6204 Q.M. Sjt:-A.S.S. Mjr: R. C. Williams. 5/Cam’n Highrs:);
Khedive's Sudan 1896-1908, (2) The Atbara, Khartoum (2489 O.R. Sgt. Williams 1. Cam. Highrs.) contemporarily engraved in the usual style associated with the Regiment

Provenance: Dix Noonan Webb, December 2018 (when sold without the MBE or 1914-15 Star).

MBE LG 3 June 1919.

MID LG 15 June 1916.

MSM LG 17 June 1918 (France - one of only two awarded to the 5th Battalion).

Roderick Chisholm Williams attested for the Cameron Highlanders on 24 April 1891 and was posted to the 1st Battalion. He served as a Sergeant in ‘A’ Company in the Sudan, and was still serving, as Quartermaster Sergeant of this Company, when he was awarded his Long Service and Good Conduct Medal in 1910. Mentioned several times in Regimental Journal, he was Recommended for an Annuity Meritorious Service Medal in 1912, and was discharged to pension on 6 July 1913, the Regimental Journal stating that nearly all his service had been spent in the Orderly Room.

Following the outbreak of the Great War Williams re-enlisted in the 3rd (Special Reserve) Battalion on 5 October 1914, and served during the Great War as an Orderly Room Sergeant with the 5th Battalion on the Western Front from 11 May to 11 November 1915. Thereafter he served as Superintending Clerk, General Headquarters, 3rd Echelon, and was discharged on 22 April 1919. For his services during the Great War he was awarded an ‘Immediate’ MSM one of only two awarded to the 5th Battalion, and was appointed a Member of the Order of the British Empire. He died in Edinburgh on 25 September 1941.

Only nine MBEs were awarded to the Cameron Highlanders for the Great War. Williams is the only Warrant Officer on the list, although there is a retired Regimental Sergeant Major who was awarded a Civil MBE for his services as Chairman of the Regimental Comforts Fund.

1195 Pte. James Lee, born 1866 in Manchester, Lancashire. Was a Laborer and enlisted on 24 December 1884 when 19 years and 10 months old into the 1st Bn. Cameron Highlanders.
He was 5’5 & ¾’ tall, with brown hair and blue eyes. He was Church of England. He had a dark mole on his right forearm.

He was discharged on 23.12.1901 after 17 years service. He served at home from 24/12/84 to 18/09/85 and then Egypt 19/09/85 to 25/03/87. He went home again from 26/03/87 to 14/02/00 and then served in S. Africa from 15/02/1900 to 16/11/01 and then returned home.

He was on “operations on upper Nile 85-6” with "Ginniss" written afterwards indicating Lee was present at the battle of Ginniss. He served in South Africa War 1900-1.
He was awarded the Egypt Medal, with no clasps; the Khedive’s Star, a QSA with CC, J, DH, Wit and SA01.

The Battle of Ginniss is considered by many to be the last battle in which the British Army wore its famous "red coats". The Cameron highlanders were in the thick of it. Although deserving of a clasp, the government did not approve it due to the low number of casualties and for political reasons.
For more information, go to: www.dcmmedals.co.uk/the-last-of-the-redc...ttle-of-ginnis-1885/
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Ginnis

Picture courtesy of Noonan's

QSA (3) Cape Colony, Orange Free State, Transvaal (1817 Pte. D. Mc.Donald. 1st. Cam’n: Highrs:);
KSA (2) (1817 Pte. D. Mc.Donald. Cameron Highrs:);
1914-15 Star (435026 Pte. D. J. MacDonald. 10/Can: Inf.);
British War and Victory Medals (435026 A. Sjt. D. J. Mac Donald. 10-Can. Inf.

Donald John MacDonald was born in Inverness, Scotland, on 20 December 1879 and served with the Queen’s Own Cameron Highlanders in South Africa during the Boer War. Subsequently emigrating to Canada, he attested for the Canadian Overseas Expeditionary Force at at Calgary, Alberta, on 6 March 1915, and served with the 10th Battalion (Alberta Regiment) during the Great War on the Western Front from 5 August 1915.

Transferring to England for Special Duties on 10 January 1918, MacDonald joined Colonel L. C. Dunsterville’s Mesopotamian Expeditionary Force, known as ‘Dunsterforce’, and embarked for Mesopotamia, landing at Basrah on 28 March 1918. He served with the famous ‘Dunsterforce’ in the Caucasus throughout 1918, and died of smallpox at Colaba Hospital, Bombay, on 5 December 1918. He is commemorated on the Kirkee Memorial, India.

Picture courtesy of Noonan's

QSA (4) Cape Colony, Orange Free State, Johannesburg, Diamond Hill (Lieut. C. G. Collins. 1/Camn. Hdrs.) engraved naming;
KSA (2) (Lieut. C. G. Collins. Cam. Hrs.) engraved naming.

Charles Glen Collins was born in 1880, the grandson of William Collins who founded the well-known publishing firm of the same name. He was educated at Cheltenham College, where he was an outstanding sportsman, and the Royal Military College Sandhurst. Commissioned into the Queen’s Own Cameron Highlanders on 14 September 1898, he joined his regiment in Cairo after the conclusion of the Sudan campaign. His colourful unpublished memoirs in the National Army Museum (Archives 2007-07-02) give a full account of the pleasures of peacetime soldiering in a crack Highland regiment. He played on the regimental polo team, shot duck and left detailed accounts of regimental customs such as dinner nights and subaltern’s court martials. His time in Egypt was not without incident. He was challenged to a duel in Alexandria after an altercation over a Hungarian dancer and he was nearly lynched in Marseilles on his way home on leave. Having pushed a drunk cab driver, who fell over, word spread along the corniche that an English officer had killed a Frenchman. Memories of the Fashoda incident were fresh and a mob soon attacked the Hotel De Noailles where Collins was staying and in his pyjamas by that time. ‘Stones and missiles were every moment breaking the windows in the hotel. The affair of the drunken cabman was beginning to assume serious proportions. At the same time loud knocking at my door announced the arrival of the hotel manager who, badly frightened, very strongly suggested that I should go out and quiet the mob. I saw that this man had completely lost his head so I slammed the door and locked it in his face. I then pushed a large wardrobe in front of the door, drew my Claymore, which happened to be among my hand luggage and decided to put up the best fight possible under the circumstances. I then saw through the window that a large body of police, both on horse and on foot, had arrived. A few minutes later, imperative orders to open my door, with the repeated mention of “Police!” caused me to push aside the wardrobe and admit a Captain of the Gendarmes. He also appeared somewhat excited so I decided it would be wise to start off by handing him a hundred franc note.’ The Boer War, Kitchener’s Fighting Scouts and Mentioned in Despatches.

Collins survived the ordeal and was later recalled from leave in England to re-join his regiment in Cairo. It was held in readiness for immediate embarkation for South Africa. The 1st Battalion Cameron Highlanders arrived in South Africa on 23 March 1900 and fought their way to Pretoria as part of the 21st Brigade in General Ian Hamilton’s force. Their exploits were well recorded by Winston Churchill in his book Ian Hamilton’s March. They covered over 2,500 miles on foot. For his part, Collins noted that Churchill and the Duke of Marlborough, on the staff, were billeted next to their lines: ‘We were always entertained by observing that the Duke invariably did all the dirty work: pitching and striking their bivouac, cooking and cleaning the pots and pans while his cousin smoked his pipe and freely criticised him.’ On 10 June 1901, Collins was appointed Adjutant of 1st Kitchener’s Fighting Scouts with the rank of local Captain. He was only twenty-one years old. Kitchener’s Fighting Scouts was an irregular regiment of volunteers raised in December 1900 and commanded by the legendary colonial warrior, Johan Colenbrander, called ‘The White Whirlwind’ by the Zulus. They fought the Boers, General Beyers and his commando especially, in the harsh Northern Transvaal. The officers and Troopers were some of the toughest Rhodesians, South Africans, Australians and Americans. They were notoriously averse to the discipline exerted by a regular Adjutant but which was required if the regiment was not to run amok, as happened to ‘Breaker’ Morant and the Bushveldt Carbineers operating in the same area. Collins’s memoirs detail some of the incidents he dealt with, including the execution of three captured Boers who were dressed in British uniform and had lured some of the KFS into a lethal ambush. Colenbrander and his men captured many Boers, their laagers, wagons and cattle but not Beyers during the guerrilla war. Colenbrander recommended Collins to Lord Kitchener for an award on 23 December 1901: ‘Capt. C. G. Collins, S.O. and Adjt. 1st K.F.S. (1st Cameron Highlanders). To whom as my Staff Officer I have always left the organisational work of the Column and to whose capability I attribute in a great part captures and successes we have been able to make’; and again on 28 April 1902: ‘Adjutant 1st K.F.S. and Staff Officer to my column to whose untiring energy and most able management I owe in great measure any success we may have accomplished. To this officer I have on all occasions entrusted the whole of the organisation of the Column, and his assistance to me has always been of the most ready and practical order’ (The National Archives, Kew, WO108/140 & 141). Collins was Mentioned in Despatches in Kitchener’s final despatches (LG 29 July 1902). Balmoral, bankruptcy, marriage and divorce in the U.S.’s ‘Gilded Age’

Collins was chosen as one of the three Cameron officers of the first King’s Guard to be mounted at Balmoral during King Edward VII’s reign. His memoirs contain much detail about life at Balmoral and the Royal family, some of it repeated in a series of articles about Collins published in the book Mississippi Gumbo by Bob Jones in 2003. Collins’s time at Balmoral got off to a shaky start when he nearly crashed his newly acquired car, a Panhard Levassor, into a coach containing the Princess of Wales and her five children including the future Kings Edward VIII and George VI. He was ordered to garage the car for the remainder of his duty. Collins was an inveterate gambler, at Monte Carlo and on the racecourse. He later attributed his financial difficulties to backing bills for his friend Charles Innes-Ker, a Gentleman Usher to the King. Whatever the cause, according to Collins it was ill-health, he resigned his commission in February 1904 before he was declared bankrupt in September 1904. By this stage he was in New York and conspicuous as a polo player and charming member of the Gilded Age set which included his friends the Vanderbilts, Goulds and Belmonts. In April 1904 he had married the American heiress Nathalie Schenck, the ‘Granddaughter of Brooklyn’. The marriage was short lived, not least because of his gambling. He lost a quarter of a million dollars on Boxing Day night in December 1904 playing baccarat at the Khedieval Club in Cairo. She divorced him in 1905. Collins spent the next ten years in recurrent financial difficulty in the United States, often reported in the U.S. papers. He set out to marry an heiress. In 1911 he was engaged to be married to Clara Parks, stepdaughter of the millionaire John H. Parks. The engagement ended when Princess Zoltykoff, the former burlesque dancer Ethel Clinton, accused him publicly of having appropriated two valuable Chinese vases from her in London seven years earlier. Soon afterwards, Collins declared personal bankruptcy in New York with debts of $414,000 (the equivalent of $10 million today) and 148 personal creditors in the United States and Europe including members of his family and Cartier jewellers in Paris. It was reported that his clothes cost $20,000 a year. The scale of the bankruptcy merited mention in The Wall Street Journal. In 1914 he attempted four times to elope with Amelia, the 30-something year-old daughter of the sewing machine manufacturer and millionaire Samuel H. Wheeler. Her incensed father hired Pinkerton detectives to stalk his every move. They managed to abort the third attempt, during which Collins had disguised himself as an old woman. Amelia was then locked in a house in Chicago with three maiden aunts. After corresponding through her hairdresser, they succeeded in August 1914 to elope at the fourth attempt. They roused a retired clergyman, who was working as a postman, out of his bed at midnight to marry them. Command of the Howe Battalion in Gallipoli campaign - twice Mentioned in Despatches.

Collins returned to England soon after and went to see Lord Kitchener at the War Office in London. He was made a Temporary Captain dated 7 October 1914 and embarked on recruiting duties in Chelsea:

‘At the end of a week I was bored to death with my job and hated the sight of the poster “Your King and Country need you.” Every few days I was called over to the War Office for a conference with [Captain] Whiffen. Early in September, I almost collided with the preoccupied and harassed looking First Lord of the Admiralty, Winston Churchill, an old fellow campaigner of Egypt, South Africa, and the polo field.
“Hello, Colenso. What the devil are you doing here?”
“Rotten job, helping to raise Kitchener’s hundred thousand.”
“Well, I’m raising a division, like to join us?” Like a flash came,
“Nothing better.”
“All right then, I’d like to have you. I’m on my way to arrange some swaps with K. You know Arnold Quilter [Lt.-Col. J. A. C. Quilter], don’t you? Go and see him and he will arrange everything.”

In this totally unexpected manner I found myself within a week transferred from a Staff Captaincy in the Army to the rank of Commander in the Navy with the post of Second-in-Command if the “Hood” Battalion of the Royal Naval Division.’ Collins was appointed Temporary Lieutenant-Commander in the R.N.VR on 26 October 1914. The Hood Battalion was commanded by Quilter and included the Prime Minister’s son, Arthur Asquith, and Rupert Brooke as officers amongst others. However, Collins, still only 34, was soon appointed as the Commanding Officer of the Howe Battalion with the rank of Temporary Commander on 24 December 1914, following the resignation of its previous C.O. after the Antwerp debacle. Commanding Officers were later transferred to the Royal Marines and Collins was gazetted as a Temporary Lieutenant-Colonel on 4 February 1915, though he insisted on wearing his Cameron glengarry. Collins trained his battalion, obtained some regular officers for it through a direct approach to the Prime Minister’s wife, paid for a band and pipers from his own pocket, and heard about the forthcoming Gallipoli campaign at a dinner at Churchill’s house along with the other Commanding Officers of the Royal Naval Division. The Howe Battalion left Blandford Camp on 20 February 1915 and embarked on the Royal George for the Mediterranean. After a spell in Egypt, Collins led his battalion ashore on the Gallipoli peninsula on the morning of 26 April and they fought their way forwards in small, isolated parties. They repulsed a Turkish attack on the 30 April to 1 May. ‘I will never forget that night so long as I live. Desperate hand-to-hand fighting lasted until dawn. In several places the British line was broken only to be recaptured by bayonet charges, with terrific cost of life’, wrote Collins. A resulting order for a counter-attack to Krithia by the Corps Commander led to further loss of life – ‘I had over half my Regiment wiped out by casualties during the first five weeks ashore. The worst was yet to come. However, drafts of new officers and men were landed nightly from Mudros to replace the casualties.’ The Howe Battalion took part in the disastrous attack, the Third Battle of Krithia, 4 June 1915 alongside the Hood, Anson and newly arrived Collingwood Battalions. 800 men of the Howe Battalion left their trenches at noon after a preliminary bombardment and attacked the Turkish trenches 250 and 350 yards to their front. Collins sent them forward in three waves, rather than the ordered two, keeping one in reserve. The trenches were taken but the French attack on the right flank was beaten back. The Turkish machine gunners in the uncaptured trenches were able to bring enfilade fire onto the trenches that had been taken. Commanding his men from the captured trenches, Collins ordered a withdrawal back to their own trenches. Within an hour, the Howe Battalion had suffered 410 casualties: 14 officers and 279 men killed and the balance wounded. The other Battalions of the 2nd Brigade of the Royal Naval Division fared even worse. The remainder of the Gallipoli campaign descended into trench warfare. The evacuation of the Gallipoli Peninsula took place on 7 January 1916. Collins reckoned that he was the only one of 96 Commanding Officers to survive from the landings to the evacuation without being killed, captured, evacuated through wounds or sickness or sacked. He was twice Mentioned in Despatches, by General Sir Ian Hamilton (LG 5 November 1915), and his successor General Sir Charles Munro (LG 12 July 1916). Later, Collins was to claim that he had been awarded the Légion d’Honneur and cited for the CMG Owing to subsequent events he did not even receive his First World War campaign medals. Resignation, arrest, imprisonment and extradition to India from the U.S.

Collins resigned his command and commission on 17 May 1916 after the return of the Howe Battalion to England. It is not clear whether this was due to his undischarged bankruptcy or because he had embarked on an affair with Elsie Muntz, the wife of a brother officer in the Royal Naval Division. He appeared in two divorce cases, the Muntz’s and his own, in 1917 and 1918. In 1917 he travelled to India with Mrs Muntz and a Mrs Olga Olsen. He bought £8,000 pounds worth of pearls from a Bombay jeweller but his drafts were not honoured. The Indian jewellers sought his extradition to Bombay to face trial for fraud. With the help of the British Embassy in New York, he was found and arrested in New Orleans. When the U.S. Marshals arrived at his ‘death-bed’ in a New York hospital to serve his extradition papers he had disappeared. He was re-arrested in New Orleans and locked up in the House of Detention. For the next five years Collins fought the longest extradition battle in US legal history. It became an international cause célèbre. For three of them he was kept in jail in New Orleans, along with the most magnificent wardrobe the jailers had ever seen. They ran his bets to the bookies and went sailing with him on the yacht he bought after winning $100,000 at the races. For two of the five years, a British police officer waited in New Orleans to escort him back to London and on to Bombay. On one occasion Collins escaped from the House of Detention taking the key to his cell as a souvenir. U.S. Marshals captured him trying to board a steamer to London. Eventually, the future U.S. President William H. Taft ruled that he should be extradited. At that stage Collins was living on bail in the French Quarter in New Orleans where he had become friends with the young author William Faulkner. He featured as Major Ayers in William Faulkner’s New Orleans novel Mosquitoes. Collins was the subject of many newspaper articles, with headlines such as ‘His Love Charmed. Dashing Lieutenant Colonel a Favorite with Women’ (The Salina Evening Journal, Kansas, 16 October 1918), ‘Capt. Glen Collins, Hero – and Rascal? The Strange Jekyll and Hyde Career of a Brave and Distinguished Officer Who Married Into the Fashionable 400 and Is Now to be Tried as Adventurer and Swindler (The Washington Times, 5 January 1919) and ‘Fresh Adventure Ahead of Collins, Soldier of Fortune – What’s that ‘something about’ him? – He Has Looks, Brains, Wit, Courage, Luck and Charm, Yet Court Says he Must Return to India Under Serious Charges’ (The Evening World, New York, 10 May 1921). Accompanied by a recently arrived British police officer he left New Orleans by boat in 1923. His friends organised a band to see him off. He stood trial twice in the High Court of Bombay. Both times he was acquitted. He returned to New Orleans in 1924 on a slow boat home, receiving a rapturous welcome from friends and another band. Collins lived reasonably quietly in New Orleans for the next fifteen years, marrying once more. He died in 1939. When told of his terminal illness he is reported to have remarked, ‘Life owes me nothing. I have tasted all of its joys.’

The pair to Lieutenant Collins sold for a hammer price of £1,800. Totals (inc VAT for UK only): £2,318. R44,800. Au$3,930. Can$3,390. US$2,460

Picture courtesy of Noonan's

Sudan (2991. Pte. H. Holdoway [sic] 1/Cam. Hrs.);
QSA (4) Cape Colony, Johannesburg, Diamond Hill, Wittebergen (2991. Pte. H. Holdaway. 1: Cam’n: Hdrs:);
KSA (2) (2991 Pte. H. Holdaway. Cameron Highrs:);
Khedive’s Sudan (2) The Atbara, Khartoum (2991. Pte. Holdaway 1 Cam Highrs) contemporarily engraved in the usual Regimental style, the obverses of the first three and the reverse of the last abrasively cleaned, heavy contact marks partially obscuring naming, suspensions somewhat loose, therefore fair to fine, the reverses generally very fine

Harry James Holdaway was born at Chalvey, Buckinghamshire, in 1874 and attested for the Cameron Highlanders at Inverness on 1 February 1892, having previously served with the 5th (Militia) Battalion, Royal Sussex Regiment.

He served with the 1st Battalion in Egypt and the Sudan from 4 October 1897 to 2 March 1900, and then in South Africa during the Boer War from 3 March 1900 to 7 November 1902.

He transferred to the Reserve on 1 February 1904, and that same year commenced work at the Royal Military College, Sandhurst, as a Cadets’ servant. The 1939 Register still lists him as being employed at the College, and hand-written date calculations on the cover of his service papers tally to 46 years and 10 months, possibly an indication as to his time spent in the army and then at Sandhurst.

He died in Camberwell, London, in January 1956.