Work on the Defence of Mafeking roll has been progressing in the last year and there is still quite a lot lot more to do.
The roll for medals with the Defence of Mafeking clasp stands at 1,307. This may reduce slightly as duplicates and roll errors are removed.
Of these, 140 were returned, leaving a figure of around 1,166 issued.
I am currently seeking extant medals. So far I have found 353 (30%) which are mostly QSAs but include the occasional KSA or BSACM.
Here is my list of extent recipients of the clasp, sorted alphabetically and by unit. The figures after the unit name show the number issued, number found and the percentage of extant medals (having removed those returned).
This is ongoing work so represents only a snapshot.
17th Lancers,3,3,100%
Kelland, Henry; Robertson, A; Robinson, Robert
9th Lancers,1,1,100%
Cavendish-Bentinck, Charles
Army Service Corps,4,4,100%
Hodgson, Nevil Bursey; Hunt, Edwin Watkin 'Ted'; Perrin, Ernest George; Ryan, Charles Montgomerie
Bechuanaland Rifles,89,29,33%
Brazer, John; Coleman, Frederick Joseph; Congdon, Charles Edward; Cooke, Lionel George James Smith; Davies, William; Forbes, Alexander; Forsyth, Robert; Galbraith, David Russell; Galbraith, Peter Tennant; Gardner, Thomas; Hall, Samuel; Hughes, H L K; Hulse, Oscar; Hyslop, George; Jardine, Ralph; Leach, Herman; Littlewood, Arthur; Lund, William Henry; Mathias, Theophilus Jones; Morse, Thomas; Nettle, Samuel; Oakden, Robert Ford; Reib, J H; Rowland, Richard; Rushton, Mark Morland; Shipman, Clarence Hubert; Smith, Frederick; Vize, Michael Joseph; Woolnough, Herbert
Border Scouts,1,1,100%
Laing, Percy
British South Africa Police,87,36,41%
Armstrong, Fraser Carleton; Ascough, Thomas Henry William Brook; Bannister, W; Brierley, Arthur Patrick; Bunbury, Duncan St Pierre; Chalke, A; Cook, A J; Cook, Frederick; Crossman, A; Daniel, Rowland Mortimer; Davies, G E; Dibbins, E; Francis, David; Francis, W; Glover, John; Holmden, Frank Alfred Amphlett (Francis); Hooper, Ernest Reginald; Hope, Adrian Lewis; Illingworth, Edward Cliffe; Jones, Albert Herbert; Knox, Herbert Henderson; Leslie, G L; Lloyd, William D'Arcy; Mackenzie, A; Marsham, Hon Douglas Henry; Newton, Frederick Charles; Panrucker, Frederick; Panzera, Francis William; Reeks, Lewis William Henry; Sell, Charles William; Smith, G; Somers, William John; Steiner, Joseph (Julius); Turbridge, Charles; Upton, Hugh Bagot 'Jimmy'; Welch, M
Cape Police,94,32,34%
Ashton, William Charles; Barnard, J; Bawtree, John Henry; Beukes, J J; Brown, Alexander John; Clements, Percy Brooke; Coxwell, Ernest William; Currie, Henry ('Harry') Miles Bowker; Dalgety, Alfred J; Doran, John Joseph; Durand, Diederick Johannes; Faulkner, Arthur Inglesby; Fentham, E; Fielding, R C; George, A; Gill, F; Glover, Alfred; Hayes, Walter Herbert; Hazlerigg, Arthur; Hipwell, Charles Henry; Jago, William; Jenkins, Hubert Harold; Loder, Arthur Charles; Maher, James Lee; Marsh, Charles Sylvester; Mynhardt, J T; Pyper, Christoffel Everard; Richards, Alexander Webb; Smith, Henry Ernest; Squair, James; Van Rensburg, F; Webb, Thomas Joseph
Colonial Contingent,1,1,100%
Goodyear, Charles
Commander in Chief's Body Guard,2,1,50%
Ramsden, Horace Edward
Driscoll's Scouts,1,1,100%
Mackenzie, Alex Thornton
Grenadier Guards,1,1,100%
Young, W H
Imperial Military Railways,1,1,100%
Blair, William
Imperial Yeomanry,1,1,100%
Tomlinson, E R
Indian Staff Corps,1,1,100%
Sandford, Harry Coddington
Irish Guards,1,1,100%
Fitzclarence, C
King's Royal Rifle Corps,1,1,100%
Parish, Thomas
Mafeking Cadet Corps,29,12,41%
Bradley, Archibald John; Brown, Allan Clement; Brown, Len; Goodyear, Warner F; McNicol, Alec; Shipman, S; Stenson, C; Stenson, I O; Stenson, W; Webster, Linden Bradfield; Whales, George; Wright, Reuben
Mafeking Railway Volunteers,6,2,33%
Adams, Myles; Andrews, Samuel
Mafeking Town Guard,407,92,23%
Aldred, Thomas A; Alldridge, R; Atherstone, A; Beckwith, W R; Benecke (Jnr), Lucas William; Bernard, W G; Bishop, K; Bland, William Carey; Bolus, Frank; Borthwick, J J; Bradfield, Horace Clement; Bradley, Hubert Henry; Brazer, David; Bridger, David Dennis; Brooks, Henry Malcolm; Bull, George; Burch, William; Campbell, Arthur; Clark, J; Clucas, Charles Wesley; Coughlan, Lawrence Charles; De Kock, John William; Dennison, Herbert Purcell; Dickinson, Arthur; Du Plessis, Franz; Dutton, Ernest Frederick; Ellercamp, Arthur; Ferry, William Henry; Friend, Arthur Henry; Gass, Richard; Gates, Lennox Mitchell; Gillespie, J; Gordon, A; Gordon, George Henry; Grant, J; Green, Luke Lot; Greenacre, George Arthur; Hall, J S; Hampton, G; Heale, George Perring; Heskins, John; Hofman, Joseph; Hommel, William Tommes Stone; Howat, John Vlotman; Hubbard, Walter; Hulley, Francis David; Hulley, James Thomas; Hulley, P W; Jacobs, F; Johnstone, Thomas; Jones, S; Kelly, J; Kidwell, C N; Lees, Alfred; Lillqvist, A; Lodge, Joseph Harry; Loubscher, A; Luyt, G C; Maguire, Thomas; McNicol, A; More, John Rhys; Muhlenbeck, Frederick August; Neilson, W; Nolte, D A; Orson, William Rose; Park, John Shearer; Parkins, ?; Peat, Thomas Baine (Bayne); Pennycook, James; Pollit, J; Rolneck, J; Royal, Alfred Henry; Schreiber, Ludwig; Sheasby (Jnr), W J; Sheasby (Snr), W S; Simonds, Gustavus William; Southall, Edwin Cuthbert; Sparks, A B; Stewart, Alexander Edward; Storey, William; Talbot, B A; Thomas, Alfred; Thomson, R F; Tighe, George Percy; Trollope, George Vincent; Van der Berg, R; Villett, R; Vince, Alfred; Walker, P; Weekes, William Hay; Weil, Benjamin Bertie; Westland, James
Marshall's Horse,1,1,100%
Morrison, John
Midland Mounted Rifles,1,1,100%
Malley, Horace St Clair
Nesbitt's Horse,2,2,100%
Taylor, Ernest Fleming; Taylor, William Sydney
Protectorate Regiment Field Force,382,106,28%
Adkins, Clement Herbert Walter; Appleton, Henry; Bailie, Henry John; Barry, Remo Henry; Bates, Edward Ulyett; Bennett, John Tillyard; Brady, William John; Bridges, George; Calderwood, Andrew Edward; Carpel, Jack Marcus; Cassidy, Dennis Patrick; Chambers, Alfred Douglas; Clark, Donald; Cloete, John Gert; Cole, Mansel Lawford; Colley, James Innes; Constable, Payton Frederick; Corby, John; Corfield, Joseph Thomas; Craig, George Patrick; Credie, James; Davie, Sydney Thomas; Davies, George Baker; Day, Arthur; Dexter, Walter Henry; Donovan, Charles; Dorgan, Frederick William Bradford; Dufton, Walter; Engle, Harry; Evans, Caradoc Ivor; Feltham, John Alric Percy; Footman, William Jackson; Frankish, Walter; Fraser, Duncan; Fuller, William Robertson; Gibbs, Joseph Walter; Gove, William Roland; Green, Arthur John; Greenwood, Richard Roberts; Hamilton, Alexander Brock; Head, Charles; Head, Henry Federick; Heery, Michael James; Hempseed, Samuel; Holmes, William George; Hotz, Henry Alexander; Impey, Cyril Brinkworth; Ireland, William; Jenner, Harry; Johnson, William Herbert; Kelly, Thomas George; Lees, Frederick William; Lukeet, Max; MacKenzie, Charles MacKillop; Magee, David; Marais, Pieter; Marlinghaus, William; Martin, Frank; Martineau, Horace Robert; McSheehy, Thomas Frederick; Miller, Albert James; Mitchell, Frederick George; Monk, Thomas William; Montgomery, Henry; Moore, John; Morgan, Walter; Munro, Joseph Geddes; Murdoch, Alfred Edwin; O’Hara, Sidney Peter; Page, Edward James 'Ted'; Palmer, Herbert; Palmer, Herbert Edward Charles; Paton, Harold Percival; Pepys, Charles John Leslie; Pickering, Kenneth Maurice; Pile, George; Pitcher, Alfred Holman; Plumb, William; Poole, Ernest Josiah; Potts, John; Powell, Thomas; Reddyoff, Tom; Ross, Hugh Lockhart; Sarril, Patrick Henry (Harry); Scandrett, Alexander Benjamin; Sherman, Percy Woodfield; Smith, Jacob; Smith, James Arthur; Smith, William Dunlop; Snow, William; Sproul, William John; Swartz, E; Sweet, Samuel; Terry, William; Thompson, John George Bird; Tucker, Algernon; Turner, Alexander Henry; Vernon, Ronald James; Von Sychowski, Edmund Franz; Wadmore, Henry Robinson; Walker, Edward Arthur; Wallis, Clarence; Walsh, Nicholas John; Ward, Bertrand Thomas; West, Lionel; Wood, Arthur Frederick
Railway Pioneer Regiment,2,1,50%
Officer, William
Royal Garrison Artillery,1,1,100%
Humphries, Ernest Edward
Scott's Railway Guards,1,1,100%
Costello, John
South African Constabulary,21,9,43%
Cooke, James; Cross, Thomas; De Ros, Dudley; Gillett, Ambrose Earl; Guttenberg, Louis Vernon; Lance, William; Parker, James Low; Rice, Thomas; White, George Samuel
Staff,1,1,100%
Cecil, Edward Herbert Gascoyne-Cecil, Lord
Western Province Mounted Rifles,1,1,100%
Longbottom, Frederick William
Absent from this list is BP himself. I have yet to track down his medals.